Assignment 1 · Notes · Part 1 · Research & Reflection

Feedback from Assignment 1

In this post, I’m going to reflect on the feedback that was given to me in regards to Assignment 1. Obviously, since it was the first I’d done, I was expecting and hoping for some constructive criticism. Whilst I enjoy writing essays and responding to an overall question, I’d not done anything like it since finishing my A Levels two years ago so wasn’t sure what exactly was expected.

I enjoyed the experience of studying independently and the responsibility that comes with it. It was hard not to procrastinate at times but overall I think I worked hard and am pleased with the content I produced in this first unit.

I’m glad I chose to keep an online learning log in the form of a blog, being able to look back at different exercises is useful and I know this will benefit me throughout the course. So far I’ve preferred to write my initial notes by hand but find it relatively easy to type them up as a final draft in my learning log.

In regards to Part A of the assignment, my tutor encouraged me to go into more detail with the points I make. For example, I should reference particular works of art rather than making more open and generic comments.

I was also reminded that I need two separate bibliographies for both Part A and B. I’d say this was definitely one area I was expecting to receive some improvements on as I’ve not used the Harvard Referencing System before. My tutor gave some helpful tips, especially in regards to the references in Part B – like ensuring I always put the last name first of the artist, author etc. I’ve now spent more time looking back at the referencing system and hope to use it in my work more consistently.

Additionally, my tutor said that I made some perceptive comments in Part B but that some were more generalised and could be improved if I backed it up with a specific piece of art. For instance, I referenced Baroque paintings but didn’t name a particular piece.

These are all things that I think should be fairly straightforward to improve upon when working towards my future assignments, however one aspect that I did have some trouble with was the word count. I’m definitely someone who writes a lot so sticking to a strict word count was a challenge and the thought of having to add in extra detail did make me wonder how on earth I’d fit it in! I actually read over my assignment again to add in some of the specific artworks and then tried to make my points more precise to stick to the word count. It was something I found easier than I thought I would and am glad I practised a bit before doing the next assignment.

At this early stage I’m not sure if I would choose to pursue Contemporary Art at a higher level, however I feel more confident in my ability to write a critical essay based on my research and know this will only improve as I progress through the course.

Overall I think the main aspects that I need to work on going ahead is my references and bibliography, as well as ensuring I utilise my research and the pieces of work I’ve looked at in my learning log. Hopefully, I can make these improvements in my future assignments.

Assignment 1

Assignment 1: research and reflection

Part A of Assignment 1 for the Contemporary Arts section is to reflect on the question ‘what is art’. I then had to reflect on what I’ve learnt, what I’d like to develop and how I think my learning log is progressing and can be improved. Below are my written notes that I used to help gather my thoughts and type up my response to the assignment.

IMG_8131

IMG_8130

For part B, I had to research ‘The Battle of Orgreave’ by Jeremy Deller and then write a 1000 word response. This should give my interpretation on the piece and reflect on the importance of time and place. Again, below are my research and essay planning notes.

IMG_8132

IMG_8133

IMG_8134

IMG_8135

Reflection in regards to assessment criteria:

Demonstration of subject-based knowledge and understanding – In my assignments I think I show a strong level of understanding and that I’ve clearly researched the subject. For instance, I didn’t know much about The Battle of Orgreave but have included various contextual information such as dates and facts to back up my response. Furthermore, I tried to convey my own opinions in order to show my understanding of the piece.

Demonstration of research skills – I believe I have displayed my research skills well as I have utilised various sources such as the internet (including articles, reviews, videos and images) and books to gather information about the subject. Additionally, I believe that the images above show that I can clearly plan and carry out a research project with the aim to write an essay.

Demonstration of critical and evaluation skills – Within my assignment, I have displayed evidence of these skills through the discussion of Deller’s piece. For instance, I evaluated the piece and questioned the concept of contemporary art and whether it can be classified as such. I also analysed the piece itself and backed up my thoughts with reviews from critics in order to synthesise contextual information and my own interpretation. In regards to the subject of time and place, I tried to show that I can engage and debate the importance of these themes within a piece of art.

Communication – I am confident in my ability to communicate my ideas in an engaging way, in order to best show the knowledge I have gained and how my thoughts develop. I like to present my response in clear paragraphs so that a clear beginning, middle and end can be identified, but also so I am able to communicate the points I want to make. Furthermore, I understand that images are not always necessary and should only be used if relevant, as I am a visual learner I believe the use of some images can help the reader to picture the subject whilst reading my interpretation. Therefore I included two images in my essay but think this is well balanced in the overall presentation.